February 28, 2011
In this strong anthology, Strahan (The Starry Rift) collects stories by some of the most talented writers in science fiction. Ranging from the first Mars landing to the far future, they often make use of the most recent scientific data about the Red Planet. In "The Old Man and the Martian Sea," Alastair Reynolds tells the exciting story of a teen who, upon running away from home, finds herself in the presence of a legendary Martian explorer. Nancy Kress, in "First Principle," explores the difficult relationship between a genetically engineered Martian teen and an embittered young man who has come to Mars as a refugee from a dying Earth. Ellen Klages touchingly recounts the birth of the first baby on Mars, while Nnedi Okorafor explains why Martians might particularly like Nigerians. Invoking some of the great authors of Martian tales, from Burroughs and Bradbury to Heinlein and Kim Stanley Robinson (whose "Discovering Life" is the only story not new to the collection), this anthology is sure to appeal to any teens who yearn to explore Earth's nearest neighbor. Ages 12–up.
March 15, 2011
This exemplary, almost old-fashioned anthology is a welcome relief in a teen fiction market dominated by dystopias, fantasy and paranormal romance. Twelve top-tier speculative fiction authors tackle the classic theme of colonizing Mars, incorporating cutting-edge science and mostly adolescent protagonists (more than half of them female) in tales of enterprise, accomplishment and sacrifice. Perhaps because they are so realistically grounded, there is a certain sameness to the stories, not just in emphasizing plausible technology and accurate environments, but also in appreciating the hard work and good luck needed to establish residence on another world. Most discount the possibility of alien life, using the futuristic far-off setting to examine contemporary issues: racism, violence, environmental damage, economic disparity and, above all, what it means to be human. The mood ranges from optimistic (seeing a virgin planet as an ideal setting to correct the errors of Terran civilization) to scathing (indicting the folly of applying failed ideologies to a new frontier) to elegiac (almost nostalgic for bygone adventures not even yet begun). While some harsh language and difficult themes might restrict the audience, readers who agree with the saw that "the Golden Age of science fiction is 12" will demand more of every author included. (Science fiction/short stories. 12 & up)
(COPYRIGHT (2011) KIRKUS REVIEWS/NIELSEN BUSINESS MEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.)
Starred review from July 1, 2011
Gr 7 Up-Strahan has assembled an impressive collection of original stories, written in a more traditional science-fiction style than most of the dystopian novels that have dominated the genre of late. Each of the 12 acclaimed authors has imagined human life on Mars (or almost on Mars) and the challenges people would face trying to tame the Red Planet. While all of the stories are good, standouts include Cory Doctorow's "Martian Chronicles," in which virtual reality becomes as important as RL and teens liberate the masses from corporate machinations. Rachel Swirsky's "The Taste of Promises" challenges our definition of life and love. And Nancy Kress's "First Principle" imagines the lengths humans might need to go to adapt to another planet and just what that means for our definition of human. Like all good science fiction, these stories, though set in the future and chock-full of scientific discoveries and innovations, are about the human condition and about relationships. By setting them in novel circumstances, the authors are able ask questions like: What makes a person a person? What are the limits of brotherly love? Are humans more than their circumstances? And what allegiances do we owe to our dreams and our promises? Teen fans of traditional sci-fi will not want to miss this collection.-Anthony C. Doyle, Livingston High School, CA
Copyright 2011 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
May 15, 2011
Grades 9-12 In 2004, President George W. Bush set a national goal to get a manned mission to Mars by 2037, and editor Strahan uses that bold plan as a challenge to top sci-fi writers to imagine stories in a world where the mission was a success. The result is this relentlessly intelligent collection that deftly mixes science, realism, and wonder. The stories are at their best when they tend toward the Bradburian: Bakers Attlee and the Long Walk deals with a childs bravery in the face of the unknown; Alastair Reynolds The Old Man and the Martian Sea is about an intergenerational passing of the torch; Ellen Klages heart-shattering Goodnight Moons focuses on a child accidentally born to Mars and unable to leave; and John Barnes Martian Heart is about no less than death itself. The odd-duck centerpiece is Cory Doctorows latest triumph about gaming and labor, Martian Chronicles, which feels like a futuristic expansion to For the Win (2010). Respect for the Red Planet is obviousnot a single author phones in his or her story.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2011, American Library Association.)
May 1, 2011
In 2004, President George W. Bush announced a goal of sending a manned mission to Mars by 2037. For this collection, editor Strahan challenged twelve authors to write stories imagining that the president's goal had been met. Each story is a planet in orbit around that common theme, each taking into account the particular conditions of Mars as setting; otherwise, as contributor Nancy Kress states, the stories "might as well be set on Earth." Ellen Klages's "Goodnight Moons" is a riff on Little House on the Prairie, only the frontier is Mars, and in the little house is a young American woman holding the first Martian baby, "the baby and the planet...both terrae incognitae." Alastair Reynolds also riffs on a classic, The Old Man and the Sea, in a story in which a girl who has grown up on Mars runs away in search of adventure. Cory Doctorow's runaway in "Martian Chronicles" is not a young girl but greed on a planet ruled by four corporations, monopolizing all wealth, power, and privilege. In contrast, Kage Baker's "Attlee and the Long Walk" imagines a socialist paradise, found boring by her young protagonist. A rich and satisfying collection of tales about old worlds left behind and new pioneers, but always implicit is the understanding that we are all -- Earthling and Martian alike -- making our own worlds and figuring out how to live in them. dean Schneider
(Copyright 2011 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)